City of Iron and Ivy
by Thomas Kent West
3 out of 5 stars
City of Iron and Ivy has one of the most imaginative premises I've encountered in a debut: an alternate London powered by floromancy, where hedge witches grow nightshade from their fingertips and a serial killer called the Reaper runs amuk. Into this world steps Elswyth Elderwood, a scarred scholar, reluctant debutante, and sister to a missing and presumed dead girl, who must find a husband and unveil the mystery of her sister's fate simultaneously.
That premise is genuinely exciting, and Thomas Kent West has real imagination. The world-building here is lush and specific in a way that many debut novels aren't, and there are scenes where the botanical magic is rendered so vividly that I was completely transported.
Where the book stumbled for me was pacing and character depth. Elswyth is an appealing protagonist, but some of her emotional beats felt underdeveloped, and the chemistry between her and Silas Blackthorn clicked into place a little faster than I believed. The mystery plot is engaging but loses some momentum in the back half, and the villain's motivations felt just-undercooked.
Still, this is a debut, and the bones here are excellent. The concept is original, the magic system is memorable, and the setting is rendered with real care. West is a writer I'll be watching closely.
For fans of Heather Fawcett, H.G. Parry, or anyone who wants their historical fantasy with a dark twist and a romantic subplot.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5)
Tropes/Themes: Dark academia, murder mystery, botanical magic, alternate history, debutante season, enemies to lovers
Tea Pairing: Rose and hibiscus herbal; beautiful, slightly thorny
Song Pairing: "Strange Magic" by Electric Light Orchestra
MY BLOG - BOOK REVIEWS, WRITER WOES, BOOK RECOMMENDATIONS, FAVE BOOKSTORES
Click Here to View my Goodreads Profile!
Please feel free to comment on my blog posts! I would love your feedback on book reviews, writer woes, book recommendations, and bookstore highlights!
Recent Posts
